GayNZ Logo & Link
Sunday 23 November 2014


Manslaughter for killing man 'who looked gay'

Posted in: New Zealand Daily News
By GayNZ.com Daily News - 17th December 2012

phillip_cottrell_1_1.jpg
Phillip Cottrell
One of two men tried for the killing of gay Wellington journalist Phillip Cottrell has been found not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter; the other has walked free.


Nicho Allan Waipuka, 20, had admitted punching Cottrell, 40, on December 10 last year, causing him to fall and hit his head on a concrete path. Between Waipuka's punching and the impact with the concrete Cottrell's skull was broken into 20 pieces. His arm was broken in two places and he suffered multiple injuries to his face and neck.

The jury heard from a number of witnesses that Waipuka and Manuel Renera Robinson, 18, had been wandering about the Boulcott Street area of downtown Wellington, with Waipuka in particular acting aggressively and spoiling for a fight. The Crown alleged that both men attacked Cottrell during which they stomped on his head.

Waipuka's girlfriend Sylvanna Robinson-Stepien, who is also Robinson's cousin, told the police investigating the case that Waipuka said he had chosen to goad and assault Cottrell because he thought the victim looked gay. However, in court she denied making this statement, accusing the police of lying about it. “It's the most rubbish shit I've heard in my life,” she told the court, while also accusing the police of corruption.

During the trial each of the defendants tried to shift the blame onto the other but the jury finally accepted that Robinson had not attacked Cottrell and had walked away during the deadly assault.


You can discuss this New Zealand gay community news story in the GayNZ.com Forum.


   Bookmark and Share




 Latest News Headlines

US: Trans woman buried as a "man"
HIV+ celeb chef was killed by hospital bug
Welsh rugby to stand against homophobia
Brazil's anti-trans violence rate 'appalling'
Gay bull saved by Simpsons co-creator
More World AIDS Day collectors needed