Auckland's High Court
|
Further back than any glbt person alive can remember gays and transgenders, and occasionally lesbians, have been singled out for extreme violence and, too often, death at the hands of those who take exception to us. In recording for posterity, and presenting to present day readers, the details of Ronald Brown's death and his killer's appointment with justice we hoped to somehow honour Brown and all those whose lives were taken or wrecked in past times because they were gay, like you.
In the past, due to the tyrany of geography, the primary gay reporting of such shocking deaths has largely been done through the eyes of straight journalists writing for general media and reported second-hand in the glbt media. Not this time. This attack and subsequent trial were in the same city where GayNZ.com is largely resourced, and so we were able to gear up to report daily and in detail, a first for NZ glbt media.
Ferdinand Ambach (Pic: NZ Herald)
|
From careful observation every day from the press bench in Courtroom 7 of the Auckland High Court through to the final sub-editing of the material into immediately published features and news stories this was a gay tragedy observed by gay people for gay people.
Ronald Brown
|
It is a defence strategy that has seen murder charges downgraded to manslaughter or less and at least one brutal assailant walk free from the court. It frequently misrepresents and demeans the gay victim and always appeals to the prejudices of jury members. Right from the start we wanted to see if and how the Ambach case played out as a possible example of 'partial defense of provocation' used in court.
There will, sadly, be more tragedies like this one. Indeed there are already two more lurking in the criminal justice queue. Although we are unlikely to be able to lavish the same resources on those cases as we have on the trial of Ferdinand Ambach for Ronald Brown's brutal death, they are no less important and no less moving.
GayNZ.com will report those cases objectively, professionally and ethically, but at the same time we fully support the call by the Law Commission, MPs and glbt organisations to have the partial defence of provocation provision struck off as a legitimate defence, with provocation relegated to an issue the judge may take into account in sentencing, as soon as possible.
- Jay Bennie
